I’d been dreading the day since the moment I remembered there was a national holiday that involved two of my biggest fears: eating and eating in front of people. That morning, after a compulsory solo turkey trot, I slipped into my baggiest clothes, hoping the volume would detract curious eyes from scrutinizing the body I was ashamed to inhabit.
Months earlier, I’d been diagnosed with anorexia nervosa, but I hadn’t shared this with anyone just yet. And the Thanksgiving table wasn’t exactly the prime place for such a revelation. My goal for the day? Make it through without completely falling apart. Yeah, good luck with that, my disorder whispered.
As my assorted family members lined up for the buffet of bland Thanksgiving staples that afternoon, I shifted my severely low weight from one foot to the other, preparing my defenses for why I wasn’t eating as much as others or why I said no to seconds.
Meanwhile, a paradoxically confusing conversation was happening in tandem: cycling through my own rationalizations for letting my body indulge on this day when indulgence is encouraged, if not required. Then I remembered—the out. The easily enactable phrases I could use to forgo any socially pressured eating. The words that had been passed down through generations for just such scenarios:
“I'm stuffed!”
“I’m saving room for dessert.”
“I was good all week so I can be bad today.”
“I’ll work this off tomorrow.”
Genius. I’d been so focused on diverting others’ attention from my plate and body that I’d completely forgotten there already existed a slate of sayings so innate, we may as well have them tattooed inside our forearms.
Now, nearly twenty years after this scene unfolded, I consider these phrases differently. I still hear them, but I no longer say them. Because by unpeeling myself from the tenets of diet culture, I now see alternative meanings for these seemingly innocuous words.
What we say versus what we might mean
I’ve spent decades in the swirls of diet culture, a large percentage of which involved disordered eating. In recovery, I’ve learned the ideals that diet messaging feeds us come preloaded with human relatability. At some point in recent decades, these phrases ingratiated themselves so deeply that not only do we feel extreme comfort employing them, but we also can be sure those around us will nod their heads in agreement. These phrases, on the surface, are so often repeated at dinner tables that we hardly bat a false eyelash when we hear them. But beneath them lingers a darker meaning, one we’d sooner laugh off than contend with. In my attempts to decode their truth, I’ve discovered they’re simply polite ways to say what we don’t want to say.
Sample translations include:
“I’m stuffed!” / “I’m saving room for dessert.”
Translation: It’s uncomfortable for me to say “no, thank you” when I’m offered another serving or when I feel dessert is pushed on me. The use of a euphemism accompanied by a jovial tone brings levity to my denial so I don’t have to hurt someone’s feelings or draw attention to the act of stopping eating. Or, genuinely, I plan to eat dessert later.
“I was good all week, so I can be bad today.”
Translation: I need to convince those around me that I restrained and restricted and sacrificed for this meal today, and that sacrifice should be seen as virtuous. And when I do eat something I enjoy, I need to justify it.
“I’ll need to work this off tomorrow!”
I need to explain that it’s important I compensate for today’s indulgence by exercising to burn off what I’ve eaten.
Although I can’t say that every phrase above has these precise corresponding hidden meanings, I can see through the forced smiles and the “Oh, I’m fine’s” that spill with ease onto the holiday dinner table. And I now know the defensive load these words carry.
Eating as performance
Which of these phrases did I use most often in the days of my eating disorder? All of them. Because when I was too thin, all I wanted was to be seen as a normal eater. So I adapted: I chose to say what I’d heard other people say about food.
Each holiday was a test to appear as normal as possible around food, for which I was doomed to fail so long as I was still in my disorder. I dug into my reserves of nonverbal cues to convey basic eating habits. I piled food onto my plate, a heaping spoonful of each dish from the buffet line resting atop the kitchen counter. I hovered a few inches behind the person in front of me, eyeing their serving size and doing my best to measure a slightly smaller amount for myself—not too much that I’d feel compelled to eat it, but enough to ward off suspicion. Whatever was going on inside had to remain imperceptible to my audience. I was performing, and my disorder was the director. I had to get every line, every movement just right in order to be believed. My goal was to convince everyone that I was fine, when I was anything but.
If someone were to make a comment, I had my arsenal of excuses ready to go: “I ate a big lunch,” “I’m saving this for leftovers,” or the like. Then a quick topic change to divert the attention away from me. I avoided spending too much time in conversation with people, just in case a glimpse of familiarity opened the door to deeper topics. I couldn’t let people get comfortable enough to get personal. I couldn’t be a person.
Why we feel the need to explain our food
As a woman shaped by the 90s and the 2000s, I was taught to apologize first, ask what I was apologizing for later. Toss a Catholic upbringing into this cornucopia of a personality, and you have an individual who is ashamed of taking up space in any way.
Nowhere is this more pronounced than the winter holiday season. We’re encouraged to indulge, yet expected to know how to moderate, because, God forbid, we roll over into the new year with work to do. The “work” being our bodies.
There’s pressure to see family, endure awkward forced connection, and actually enjoy the season, but with expectations weighing us down, merriment is harder to openly accept.
And if we decide we don’t want to follow familial or cultural traditions around abundance, we’re given the side eye, as if we’re personally offending the people around us, or the holiday itself.
In this scene, there were likely other people at that table who feared this day, who were worried about their ability to get through it without feeling guilty, who were already planning ways to burn off the meal we’re supposed to be thankful for. With so many expectations, preconceptions, and learned messaging about this holiday, some of us require a great deal of effort not to be preoccupied with eating this time of year. But still, that admission is best hidden beneath the table.
Learning to leave food unexplained
Even after two decades in eating disorder recovery, I still (sometimes) mentally mine for explanations for my food decisions. At times, I find them waiting on the cusp of my lips, ready to deploy at the first untoward comment about my meal. Releasing this urge and learning new tactics, like staying still in moments of discomfort, have been valuable foundations of my recovery. And now I am more acutely aware of how not responsible I am for others’ opinions about my eating behaviors.
Traditions aren’t built around making us feel guilty for not doing them. They’re built from a desired sense of community and belonging. Choosing to abstain from or change a tradition shouldn’t cast us out of the tribe, but rather be considered a personal decision that helps us feel safe coming back to the tribe, year after year. What we decide to eat doesn’t need to invite commentary or stir up disgust in ourselves. Instead of defending our decisions, we can rewrite what they mean and share these edits with our loved ones as a bid for connection, rather than with a fear of judgment.
Back at the Thanksgiving table from twenty years ago, I see a young woman who still has a lot to learn. She lacks confidence. She’s not ready to come to terms with her beliefs and behaviors around food. She still feels the strong urge to defend her choices. And all she wants is to be invisible.
But today, I can see what she really wants: for food to exist without judgment, opinions, or pressure. And not just from the people at this table, but from culture, society, the media, her peers—everyone. On a holiday that historically revolves around food, she can choose to make it about something else, and leave her emotional support phrases in Thanksgivings past.
Pause & Prompt
What might it look like to say what you’re really feeling rather than hide behind some of these phrases?